FIDIC notes

Ten years after handover

Decennial liability under Egyptian law, and the FIDIC clauses that cannot exclude it.

[date] · [author] · 6 min read

A construction contract usually ends with a taking over certificate, then a defects notification period, then a performance certificate. Many contractors assume their liability ends there. The Egyptian Civil Code keeps architects and contractors liable for ten years after handover, and no contract can remove that.

The text

Article 651, in its first three paragraphs:

«يضمن المهندس المعماري والمقاول متضامنين ما يحدث خلال عشر سنوات من تهدم كلي أو جزئي فيما شيدوه من مبان أو أقاموه من منشآت ثابتة أخرى...» The architect and the contractor are jointly liable for any total or partial collapse, within ten years, of the buildings or other fixed structures they built, even if the collapse comes from a defect in the ground itself, or the employer approved the defective works, unless the parties intended the structures to last less than ten years.

«ويشمل الضمان المنصوص عليه في الفقرة السابقة ما يوجد في المباني والمنشآت من عيوب يترتب عليها تهديد متانة البناء وسلامته». The liability also covers defects that threaten the building's stability and safety.

«وتبدأ مدة السنوات العشر من وقت تسلم العمل». The ten years run from handover of the work.

Article 652 limits an architect who only produced the design, without supervising the works, to design defects. Article 653 settles the contractual question: «يكون باطلا كل شرط يقصد به إعفاء المهندس المعماري والمقاول من الضمان أو الحد منه»: any term meant to exclude or limit the liability is void. Article 654 sets the time to sue: «تسقط دعاوى الضمان المتقدمة بانقضاء ثلاث سنوات من وقت حصول التهدم أو انكشاف العيب», three years from the collapse or the discovery of the defect.

Three periods not to confuse

  • The liability period: ten years from handover, within which the collapse must happen or the defect appear.
  • The time to sue: three years from the collapse or the discovery of the defect (Article 654).
  • FIDIC's defects notification period: set in the Contract Data, a contractual duty to fix defects, not a substitute for decennial liability.

The FIDIC clauses that cannot exclude it

Clause 1.15 (Limitation of Liability) caps the contractor's total liability and excludes loss of profit and indirect loss, and the cap does not apply to fraud, gross negligence, deliberate default or reckless misconduct. In Egypt the cap cannot limit decennial liability at all, because Article 653 voids any term that limits it.

Clause 11.10 (Unfulfilled Obligations) keeps each party liable for obligations still unperformed after the performance certificate, but for Plant it ends the contractor's liability for defects occurring more than two years after the defects notification period expires, except where the law prohibits that. Where a defect falls within Article 651, Egyptian law does.

One question remains: the ten years run from «تسلم العمل», handover of the work. Which event in a FIDIC contract counts as that handover, the taking over certificate or a later one, is a point to settle in the contract and check with counsel.

Why a general model gets this wrong

Decennial liability comes from the civil law tradition: French law (Article 1792 and following of the French Civil Code) and the Arab codes that drew on it. Most of what is written in English about construction contracts, which is most of what a general model trained on, talks about defects notification periods and English limitation periods. Ask a model "when does a contractor's liability end?" and the most likely answer in its training text is: when the defects notification period ends, subject to the cap in clause 1.15. If it does recall decennial liability, it may give the French version, which also covers defects that make a building unfit for its intended purpose, wider than the Egyptian words: «عيوب يترتب عليها تهديد متانة البناء وسلامته». Two close ideas, two different texts, and one fluent answer that blends them.

In Bayan

Ask Bayan about decennial liability and it quotes Articles 651 to 654 in full, with the Court of Cassation rulings on its scope and on when the period starts. In Bayan Clause Intelligence, the FIDIC track flags any wording in clauses 1.15 and 11.10, or in the Particular Conditions, that appears to limit it.

Share

The month's key legal updates and what's new in Bayan, once a month.

Ask Bayan your first question.

Or book a team demo and bring a real contract: thirty minutes is enough to know whether Bayan fits your practice.

Book a team demo