FIDIC notes

The 28 day notice in FIDIC 2017

How a claim is lost, and how to protect it from day one.

[date] · [author] · 7 min read

On large construction projects in Egypt, the contract is often written on one of the FIDIC 2017 forms. Those forms hold a short deadline that decides the fate of claims more than any other clause: 28 days to send a Notice of Claim. Miss it and you can lose your right to more time and more money, however fair the claim.

What clause 20.2.1 says

A party that considers itself entitled to a claim must give a Notice of Claim as soon as practicable, and no later than 28 days after it became aware, or should have become aware, of the event or circumstance. If it does not give notice within that period, it is not entitled to an extension of time or additional payment, and the other party is discharged from liability for that event.

Notice the words "should have become aware". The clock does not only start on the day you actually found out; it starts on the day a careful contractor would have known.

After the notice: 14 days for the Engineer

If the Engineer considers the notice late, clause 20.2.2 requires the Engineer to say so within 14 days of receiving it, with reasons. If the Engineer does not, the notice is treated as valid, though the other party can still disagree.

Then 84 days for the detailed claim

Clause 20.2.4 requires a fully detailed claim within 84 days of becoming aware of the event: a description of the event, the contractual or other legal basis of the claim, the contemporary records, and the supporting particulars. If the statement of the contractual or legal basis is not submitted within that time, the Notice of Claim is treated as having lapsed.

A door that does not fully close

Clause 20.2.5 allows the Engineer, when agreeing or determining the claim, to consider whether a late submission is justified, including how far the other party would be prejudiced by accepting it. It is a narrow door. Do not build your plan on it.

What Egyptian law says

Article 388(1) of the Civil Code: «لا يجوز النزول عن التقادم قبل ثبوت الحق فيه، كما لا يجوز الاتفاق على أن يتم التقادم في مدة تختلف عن المدة التي عينها القانون». Prescription cannot be waived before the right arises, and the parties cannot agree a prescription period different from the one the law sets. Hence a well known debate among Egyptian lawyers: is the 28 day bar a change to a prescription period, and so void, or a procedural condition the parties agreed, and so valid? The answer can turn on how the clause is drafted and characterised, and on the view of the court or tribunal. Article 148(1) also requires a contract to be performed in line with its terms and as good faith requires, an argument for a contractor whose employer knew of the event from day one. Do not rely on the debate. Send the notice on time.

How to protect a claim from day one

  1. Keep a notice register on site, reviewed every week, listing every event that might lead to a claim.
  2. When in doubt, send the notice. A notice you did not need costs you nothing; a notice you did not send can cost you the whole claim.
  3. Follow the form clause 1.3 requires: in writing, identified as a Notice, and sent by the means the contract allows.
  4. Keep contemporary records from the first day: minutes, dated photographs, correspondence.
  5. Read the Particular Conditions. Many employers shorten the 28 days or delete clause 20.2.5.

Why a general model gets this wrong

FIDIC's forms are sold, not published free, so a general model did not learn clause 20.2 from its text. It learned from what has been written about it. Far more has been written about the 1999 forms than the 2017 forms, because the 1999 forms have been in use for over twenty years. In the 1999 forms, notice sits in clause 20.1 and the detailed claim is due within 42 days. Ask a general model about a 2017 contract and it may answer with the 1999 numbers and clause references, because they are the most likely ones in its training text. It answers both versions with the same confidence, so nothing in the wording tells you which edition you are reading.

In Bayan

In Bayan Clause Intelligence, the FIDIC track reads your contract, General and Particular Conditions together, so the notice periods it shows are the ones in your contract. It flags every amendment to Clause 20 and its effect, with the Egyptian provision it touches. The analysis is in English.

Share

The month's key legal updates and what's new in Bayan, once a month.

Ask Bayan your first question.

Or book a team demo and bring a real contract: thirty minutes is enough to know whether Bayan fits your practice.

Book a team demo