FIDIC notes

Particular Conditions

The amendments that move risk without anyone noticing.

[date] · [author] · 7 min read

A FIDIC contract has two parts: General Conditions that everyone knows, and Particular Conditions written for each project. In Part B of the Particular Conditions, the General Conditions are amended, deleted or added to. A quick review reads the General Conditions because they are familiar, and skims the Particular Conditions. That is exactly where risk moves.

The Golden Principles

In 2019 FIDIC published five Golden Principles for drafting Particular Conditions. In short: the parties' roles and responsibilities should stay, in substance, as the General Conditions set them; the Particular Conditions should be drafted clearly and without ambiguity; they should not change the balance of risk and reward that the General Conditions strike; every time period should be reasonable; and formal disputes should go to a dispute board before arbitration, unless that conflicts with the governing law. A contract that departs from these principles is still a valid contract, but it is no longer a FIDIC contract in the sense FIDIC means.

Five amendments that move risk quietly

  1. Deleting or narrowing clause 4.12. It gives the contractor relief when it meets physical conditions it could not have foreseen, such as ground unlike what the surveys showed. Deleting it moves all ground risk to the contractor.
  2. Amending clause 3.7. In the 2017 forms, the Engineer acts neutrally when agreeing or determining claims. An amendment that makes the Engineer act for the employer at that stage changes the nature of every claim.
  3. Shortening the periods in clause 20.2, such as turning 28 days into 14, or deleting clause 20.2.5, which allows a justified late submission to be accepted.
  4. Lengthening payment periods in Clause 14, or deleting financing charges for late payment.
  5. Deleting the dispute board and going straight to arbitration or the courts, against the fifth Golden Principle.

What Particular Conditions cannot change

Egyptian law sits above any Particular Condition at specific points:

  1. No exclusion for one's own fraud or gross fault in contract, and no exclusion at all of liability in tort (Article 217).
  2. The judge may reduce agreed compensation, delay damages included, if it is grossly excessive or the obligation was partly performed, and any agreement to the contrary is void (Article 224).
  3. Any agreement against the rule on unforeseen circumstances is void (Article 147(2)).
  4. Any term that excludes or limits the decennial liability of architects and contractors is void (Article 653).
  5. In disputes over administrative contracts, the Arbitration Law (Law 27 of 1994) makes an agreement to arbitrate valid only with the approval of the competent minister, and that approval cannot be delegated.

Why a general model gets this wrong

FIDIC's General Conditions have been discussed in thousands of articles and books. The Particular Conditions of your project are known only to its parties. Ask a general model "what does clause 4.12 say?" and it answers from the General Conditions, because that is the most likely answer in everything it has read. It cannot know your contract deleted the clause. The answer is right in general and wrong for your contract. There is a second effect. After training, models are tuned toward answers people prefer, and Anthropic's research found that this tuning pushes them to agree with the person asking. Ask "is this amendment standard?" and the model leans toward yes. The right question is not "what does FIDIC say?" but "what does my contract say, and what does Egyptian law say above it?"

In Bayan

The FIDIC track in Bayan Clause Intelligence reads the Particular Conditions against the General Conditions, shows each amendment in place, and flags the ones that move risk and the ones Egyptian law overrides, each with its text. The analysis is in English.

Sources. FIDIC, "FIDIC Golden Principles", 2019 · Sharma et al., "Towards Understanding Sycophancy in Language Models", Anthropic, ICLR 2024.

Share

The month's key legal updates and what's new in Bayan, once a month.

Ask Bayan your first question.

Or book a team demo and bring a real contract: thirty minutes is enough to know whether Bayan fits your practice.

Book a team demo